New Orleans The Democratic Socialists of American (DSA) has had a good electoral season. Their membership is higher than it has been in almost 100 years. Candidates carrying their support and moniker have been elected to Congress, as mayors in major cities, in legislatures, on city councils, and more. In the midterm cycle for the most part, they even weathered a steady barrage of red-baiting from the White House on down as unrestrained radicals. These are the facts, ma’am. There’s no sense in arguing about that.
Their success also seems to mean a closer look behind the curtain at the mess that characterizes making sausage and maintaining democracy, including in progressive organizations. Recent articles in both the New Yorker and the New York Times try to provide some kind of inside look. There was a surge of such pieces after Mamdani’s election in New York City, and now the election of Nithya Raman in Los Angeles, seems to have triggered yet more. The flirtation of Alexandria Ocasio Cortez, the famed AOC, and her supporters over a run for the White House in 2028 will encourage even more speculation.
A lot of this is an effort to subtly encourage moderation, as if most of progressive policies weren’t pretty much middle of the road, apple pie already. It’s an effort to define the extremes within the movement in order to try to position many of the newly elected somewhere on the spectrum as somehow what the publicans and the reporters seem as more acceptable to the mass population and electorate. Frankly, good luck with that.
I can remember coming out of a workshop on ACORN in Philly, where, as is my habit, at the beginning I had asked the participants to identify themselves and their organizations. Later, I had asked the organizer to help me understand the difference between various socialist groups that were mentioned whether DSA, Philly Socialists, or others. He laughed and said there were about six different socialist clubs and groups in the city alone. For my money, that’s pretty healthy, and the voting totals are clear, no matter the coffeehouse arguments on specific planks in an emerging program, when a candidate is on the ballot, all of them are pulling the lever together.
All of this particularly swirls around Mayor Raman. She began her campaign waving her membership card in DSA predating her announcement that she was running by several years, but many felt her campaign didn’t reflect a program as progressive as that label might have implied. Rather than being a “sewer socialist” as elected socialists had described themselves earlier in the 20th century, she was more a “tech socialist”. As one reporter describer her program, she
…didn’t talk about defunding police, removing the private sector from housing construction or other items from a D.S.A. wish list. Rather, she outlined a near future of mapping out trouble spots and restructuring org charts. She would launch dashboards and audits, she said, and base performance evaluations on results and metrics.
More accurately, Raman didn’t fit the caricatures of the left. She sounded like someone who was probably trying to consolidate her political base, rather than be the square peg that the mainstream press had hoped they could force into the hole.
The real problem in electing progressive politicians is not the fact that they do what they must do to build a base and build power, but whether they are accountable. ACORN found in electing members that sometimes they were more accountable when multiple members were elected together, so that there were both inside and outside boundaries that could be drawn.
For Raman and so many others the answers to the real tests are still in the future, and they are almost biblical. When the chips are down, will they deny their politics and support before the cock crows thrice? The various sects and strains of socialism today need to be as united then, as they were at the ballot box earlier. If not, the banner waving politicians now will be simply free agents like the rest of the gang.
