Tag Archives: housing

Land Contracts Are Back in the Census

New Orleans         All of the controversy on questions in the 2020 American Community Survey, conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau, has been about whether a question would be allowed about citizenship.  The federal courts pretty much slammed the door on that question when one judge after another essentially caught the White House and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross separating their answers from their malevolent intentions.  Of course, even so NPR discovered last summer that they had included the question in test surveys sent to hundreds of thousands, called them on it, and they once again promised to remove the question following the standard Trump administration playbook of “catch us if you can.”

The Census hasn’t showed up where we live, but it did show up in the mailbox of my parents’ house.  Knowing how important the American Community Survey is to policies that impact all of us, I opened it with interest, so I could complete the form.

The citizenship question was not included.  On the other hand, if you didn’t speak English or own a computer, you would be stuck-like-Chuck.  There was one large card that was in English on one side and Spanish on the other.  The Spanish side, sent you to the internet to respond.  Good luck with that!  Another option was to mail the form in, but of course that would have meant getting it translated by someone, so that the questions could be answered.  Any problems, they suggested calling an 800-number.  We’ll have to look into this.

There was some good news though, especially for the ACORN Home Savers’ Campaign and everyone who has been trying to track predatory practices involving lower income families and tenants.  In the series of questions about your home, one tried to drill down on the question of ownership financing.  Choices included whether or not you owned the home outright, had a mortgage, or, most importantly to us, whether or not you had a “contract to purchase.”

When I looked up the Census Bureau survey questions on their website, the housing section seemed slightly different than the actual form I had filled out for my parents’ home.  One question on their form was more pointedly about flood insurance for example.  The question in the sample booklet included fire, flood, and other hazards.  Possibly, there are different questions in different parts of the country or maybe this was a test mailing.

I don’t want to get distracted though or take any of you off course.  Including a question once again on land installment contracts is important.  For whatever reason, it dropped off the 2010 Census even as land contracts exploded in many cities after the Great Recession of 2007-2008.  The omission of the question left us scrambling to prove how pervasive the surge of land contracts was across the country.  We could access some private real estate data, but that’s not as good as the gold standard Census work on the American Community Survey. Other public data establishing that more land contracts were being registered in Detroit than mortgages were hard to duplicate in many cities where records were less transparent and classifications were different.  Being thankful for small favors, especially when it comes to the current government, the inclusion of this question should in the next several years give us a better sense of the magnitude of this issue.

The information will still be imperfect because so many holders of such contracts have been misled into believing that they have a mortgage rather than a no-equity installment plan.  Nonetheless, asking about whether anyone in the home has a “contract to purchase” is a pretty comprehensive way to phrase the question to get at most of these situations.

None of this solves the problem, but at least including the questions, and more importantly, getting the answers, moves these predatory practices out of the real estate closet and into the open where we can force solutions for families caught in many of these predatory webs.


Rental Rip-offs, Big, Small, and Dangerous

New Orleans      The rental market in the USA is the wild west.  Not the west where the “deer and the buffalo roam” and “the skies are never cloudy.”  That’s long gone.  The rental mark in America is now the wild west of HBO’s “Deadwood” and the Massacre at Wounded Knee.

On the high end, Blackstone Group, the giant Wall Street private equity outfit, has just cashed out of its last remaining stake in its rental home business created from the 2008 foreclosure crisis, reaping about $7 billion from start to finish.  They caught a whooper by bottom fishing on family misery.  The ACORN Home Savers Campaign was recently in Memphis documenting for the Hooks Institute how they and others had hijacked the rental housing market in the city.

The rental crisis is everywhere.  Twenty-three million people — overwhelmingly children, working adults, seniors, and people with disabilities — live in a low-income household that pays more than half of its income for rent. Roughly one in three renters in Los Angeles reports spending more than half of their income on housing, census data shows.  The gap between median renter income and median rent widened in 2018, new Census data show, with median rent rising 2.1 percent in inflation-adjusted terms but median renter household income rising just 1.6 percent, to $40,500.

Let’s agree.  It’s bad out there for renters.  Worse for some than others.

Take for example on the low end, the recent horror stories reported in Little Rock in an almost 5000-word piece in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette about the 1000-units there owned and operated with impunity by the Chicago-based AMG Rental Group.

How bad?  Well, this bad:

Since 2018, AMG properties in Pulaski County have racked up more than 1,000 code enforcement violations, although the company did not own all of the properties for all of that period, records show.  As of November, AMG owned or managed at least six properties with 935 apartments in Little Rock and one property with 92 apartments in North Little Rock, according to public records. In the past year, code inspectors found as many as 16 violations in one apartment. They cited the company’s apartments for 1,162 violations.  About 35% of the total violations — more than 400 — were for life-safety issues, such as exposed wiring or faulty smoke alarms that could endanger a tenant’s life. Those violations are supposed to be addressed more quickly than other types of code violations.

AMG’s website says their investment strategy:

…focuses on acquiring overlooked and undervalued multi-family assets, with the potential to add value via a repositioning of the property, including operationally, structurally or financially. AMG seeks neglected assets that combine a strategic location and low cost basis. Once we acquire a property, we manage the property “in house”, which results in a clear alignment of interest between ourselves, our investors and our residents.

In other words, they’re bottom fishing with a vengeance.

Little Rock inspectors say they are getting better and making progress.  Little Rock police barred the reporter from the property despite having an invitation to visit by a tenant.  The record elsewhere indicates, that their disregard and manipulation of tenants and violations of habitability codes is not an anomaly, but a business model.  As the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette reported:

Concerns over tenant safety led Ohio officials to sue AMG, the Hot Springs Housing Authority to stop sending housing voucher business to one of its complexes and Tulsa officials to close an entire complex.  In Columbus, Ohio, city attorney Zach Klein filed what his office touted as the “largest public nuisance lawsuit” in the city’s history.  Before Klein filed suit in September 2018, the city had imposed $1,000 daily fines, allowed under a 2014 law that penalizes “negligent property owners.”  AMG, the first company to receive such a sanction, racked up at least $75,000 in fines. “Filing a lawsuit of this size and scope became necessary, because of the property owner’s troubling pattern of ignoring the city’s orders to fix a series of code violations,” Klein said in the news release.  “We already have evidence of harm and injury to our residents, so it’s imperative for us to get every one of AMG’s apartments under court order to force them to take their tenants’ safety seriously,” the city attorney said.

The underbelly of escalating rents, callous evictions at record levels, and costs that suck the life blood out of family budgets is more than financial.  The real price is in human suffering and personal, permanent harm.  AMG Realty Group is one of many.  They and others must be stopped.  Tenants are starting to organize.  They need our support.  Their lives depend on it!